Buying your first car is an exciting milestone, but with so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming. First-time buyers need a car that’s affordable, reliable, fuel-efficient, and easy to maintain.
This guide highlights the best used and new cars for first-time buyers in 2025, focusing on budget-friendly options with low ownership costs and strong resale value.
What to Look for in a First Car
When choosing a first car, consider:
✔ Affordability – Look for models with low purchase prices and cheap insurance rates.
✔ Reliability – Pick vehicles known for long-term durability and low repair costs.
✔ Fuel Efficiency – A car with good MPG saves you money at the pump.
✔ Safety Features – High crash-test ratings and modern safety tech (backup cameras, blind-spot monitoring, etc.).
✔ Low Maintenance Costs – Some cars are cheaper to maintain than others—avoid models with expensive repairs.
Best Used Cars for First-Time Buyers (Affordable & Reliable)
1. 2016-2021 Toyota Corolla
- Why It’s Great: The Corolla is one of the most reliable compact cars ever made.
- MPG: 30-40 city/highway
- Pros: Low insurance rates, high resale value, great gas mileage.
- Best For: Commuters and budget-conscious drivers.
2. 2015-2020 Honda Civic
- Why It’s Great: The Civic blends reliability, fuel efficiency, and sporty styling.
- MPG: 30-41 city/highway
- Pros: Fun to drive, high resale value, good safety ratings.
- Best For: First-time buyers looking for a mix of style and practicality.
3. 2014-2019 Toyota Camry
- Why It’s Great: A dependable midsize sedan with a smooth ride and high safety scores.
- MPG: 25-39 city/highway
- Pros: Spacious interior, low maintenance costs, long-lasting engine.
- Best For: Drivers who want a comfortable, reliable ride.
4. 2016-2021 Hyundai Elantra
- Why It’s Great: The Elantra is an affordable compact car with good fuel efficiency.
- MPG: 28-38 city/highway
- Pros: Budget-friendly, long warranty, solid tech features.
- Best For: Buyers on a tight budget looking for a newer car.
5. 2015-2020 Honda Fit
- Why It’s Great: A hatchback with surprising cargo space, great for city driving.
- MPG: 29-40 city/highway
- Pros: Affordable, easy to park, great resale value.
- Best For: College students and young professionals who need flexibility.
6. 2014-2019 Mazda3
- Why It’s Great: A sporty compact car with a sleek design and fun driving experience.
- MPG: 27-40 city/highway
- Pros: Stylish, reliable, great fuel economy.
- Best For: First-time buyers who want a fun but practical car.
7. 2016-2021 Nissan Sentra
- Why It’s Great: A budget-friendly sedan with good fuel economy.
- MPG: 27-37 city/highway
- Pros: Affordable to insure, smooth ride, roomy interior.
- Best For: Buyers looking for a cheap, fuel-efficient commuter.
8. 2015-2020 Subaru Impreza
- Why It’s Great: A compact sedan or hatchback with all-wheel drive for all-weather capability.
- MPG: 22-36 city/highway
- Pros: Standard AWD, good resale value, solid safety ratings.
- Best For: Drivers in snowy or rainy climates.
Best New Cars for First-Time Buyers in 2025
If you’re considering a brand-new car, these models offer affordability, safety, and modern tech features:
✔ 2025 Toyota Corolla – Reliable, fuel-efficient, great resale value.
✔ 2025 Honda Civic – Sporty and fun to drive, packed with safety features.
✔ 2025 Hyundai Elantra – Budget-friendly compact with an industry-leading warranty.
✔ 2025 Nissan Versa – One of the cheapest new cars, great for first-time buyers.
✔ 2025 Kia Forte – Modern styling with great fuel economy and affordability.
Tips for First-Time Car Buyers
1. Set a Realistic Budget
- Keep your car payment under 15% of your monthly income.
- Consider insurance, maintenance, and fuel costs before choosing a car.
2. Get Pre-Approved for Financing
- Explore Buy Here Pay Here dealerships for easy bad credit approval.
- Compare auto loan rates from banks, credit unions, and online lenders.
3. Prioritize a Vehicle with Low Ownership Costs
- Research insurance costs before buying—some cars are more expensive to insure.
- Choose a car with a reputation for reliability to avoid costly repairs.
4. Check Vehicle History & Get an Inspection
- Always check CARFAX or AutoCheck before purchasing a used car.
- Have a trusted mechanic inspect the vehicle before buying.
5. Look for Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Models
- CPO cars offer warranties and inspections, giving first-time buyers extra peace of mind.
Final Thoughts: Choosing the Best First Car
First-time buyers should focus on affordable, reliable, and fuel-efficient cars that are cheap to maintain and easy to drive. Whether you go for a budget-friendly used model or a brand-new entry-level car, these options provide the best value for new drivers.
If you’re ready to buy your first car with flexible financing, check out our Buy Here Pay Here dealership options today!
